See I was the same way with sports games, I always hated them.-Halo Franchise
-All Sports Games
That's all I can think of for now.
Then I discovered NBA 2k10 (2k11 now) and Fifa 10 & 11. I really like those games a lot. Gran Turismo (racing) games are great.
Football games are really boring for me as well as most other sports games though. I do like a few now even though I used to hate them all. They're a lot worse on the wii.