I say that the black one is the best of them all. It was done with more detail and smoothness and the font does kinda fit. I like the glossy bit on it too. The Blue one is Elvish is awesome! Who knew text and bg could look so good^^; The red one I am iffy about because of the bg. I don't think it goes well with the pic or the font(Though those two go great together). Try something else with that one and u just might be more satisfied than u were with it the first time.
The first one is awesome. I don't know why but I really like it. The 2nd one is nice, it's different. But most people would be turning their monitors upside down just to see what it says. The 3rd one is not bad either.