The Who's better game (hockey)

Babe_Ruth

Sultan of Swat
Staff member
V.I.P.
#1
I'll start with a pair of players and you tell me who you think is better (but please provide a reason!) then you add your own two players to face off.

Sidney Crosby or Joe Thorton?
 

andrew_bishop

#1 Spammer of FC
#2
As much as I don't like to say it Crosby because all around he is the best puck handler in the league and he is the future of the game as we know it.

Eric Stall or Malkin?
 

Babe_Ruth

Sultan of Swat
Staff member
V.I.P.
#3
Eric Stall: Even though Evegeni Malkin as 28 goal this year Eric Stall as a Stanley Cup and he's a way better passer then Malkin.

Vincent Lecavalier or Martin St Louis?
 

Turbo

Registered Member
#4
St. Louis without a doubt; he's small and fast with great puck handling ability and a great eye for the game.

Patrick Roy or Martin Broduer?
 

Kazmarov

For a Free Scotland
#5
Roy, barely. Once Brodeur finishes his career and we can look back at their careers in paralell, we'll see.

Giguere or Pronger?
 

Babe_Ruth

Sultan of Swat
Staff member
V.I.P.
#6
Well it's kinda hard comparing a defencemen to a goaltender, but I'd have to say Chris Pronger because he's been more valuable to the teams he's been playing for the Giguere as been for the ducks.

Alexander Semin or Jordan Stall
 

Turbo

Registered Member
#7
Hmm, I'm gonna say Semin because he was a surprise where all the Staahls should be stars.

Tom Poti or Zdeno Chara?
 

Babe_Ruth

Sultan of Swat
Staff member
V.I.P.
#9
That's very hard, but i'll go with Raycroft because is team as a better record. Plus Raycroft won the Rookie of year.

Daniel Briere or Joe Sakic
 
#10
Sakic mostly due to his experience and his pure talent compared to the younger Briere who might be good but I don't think he will quite as good as Sakic.

As for the one I just said about Thomas and Raycroft I think both goalies have their moments and are big to their teams for sure. If either of those don't play good chances are the team won't win. Raycroft might have been rookie of the year but he has steuggled a little since then but his last stretch with the Leafs I think he showed he can play with the best in the NHL. My choice would be Raycroft too but not by much.

Anyway , Dan Boyle or Thomas Kaberle?