• Welcome to the PopMalt Forums! Whether you're new to forums or a veteran, welcome to our humble home on the web! We're a 20-year old forum community with thousands of discussions on entertainment, lifestyle, leisure, and more.

    Our rules are simple. Be nice and don't spam. Registration is free, so what are you waiting for? Join today!.

Teen charged in bizarre missing dog case


Registered Member
Quoted from here.

PHILADELPHIA - A telephone call at midnight normally would have awoken Bill Whiting, but he hadn't been sleeping much since his dog disappeared. He picked up the phone and couldn't believe what he heard.

Children were demanding $600 or else they would kill Edna, his beloved beagle mix. Whiting listened in horror to what sounded like the jingle of Edna's collar, and an animal yelping in pain. He agreed to pay the ransom.

"You don't understand, mister," a boy replied. "I want to kill your dog anyway."

What happened to Edna remains a mystery, but Philadelphia police have charged a 15-year-old with harassment, terroristic threats, theft by extortion and other counts for allegedly calling Whiting. Police have yet to find the dog.

Authorities gave no immediate explanation for how they traced the call.

"I've had tears today a couple of times. I don't see any happy news in this," a heartbroken Whiting said Friday. "I don't have a dog coming back, apparently." He also said he believes at least two children were involved.

Edna had been Whiting's constant companion for more than 10 years. The 57-year-old employee of the University of Pennsylvania's archaeology museum described Edna as a gentle dog that loved children and had been a therapy animal at nursing homes and hospitals.

Edna vanished on Halloween, after Whiting and the dog walked from his home in Philadelphia to a friend's house. Whiting thinks she slipped out into the unfamiliar neighborhood while the door was open for trick-or-treaters.

Frantic, he looked for hours, then printed up "Missing Dog" posters and plastered them around the neighborhood. The posters contained his cell phone number and offered a $500 reward.

Ten days after the dog disappeared, Whiting received the midnight call on his cell phone from a youth who demanded $600. Then a younger boy got on the phone and apparently began abusing an animal.

Whiting said he didn't recognize the yelps, since he had never heard Edna hurt before, but detected the sound of her collar, which had numerous tags and "jangled like a charm bracelet."

He begged them not to hurt the dog, and simultaneously dialed police from his land line.

Whiting went to a police station in the middle of the night to make a report. When he returned home a few hours later, his land line rang almost immediately. "We killed your dog," the voice said. "It's dead."

Whiting began to believe the children really did have Edna, since the land line phone number was only on the dog's tags, not the poster.

"I became hysterical," he said. "I started to tremble."

Police worked for weeks on tracing the calls, whose numbers came up as unavailable on Whiting's Caller ID. Publicity led to an outpouring of support for Whiting and rage against the perpetrators; rewards were offered by animal advocacy groups.

On Dec. 30, police arrested the 15-year-old, who was released to his family for a hearing Jan. 31.
My first thought after reading this was 'If that were my kid, he'd be safer in jail, because I'd beat his ass into the ground if he came back home.'

What the fuck? I have no faith in humanity, really.


New Member
That's messed up. Parents gotta put their foot down.


Secret Agent
Staff member
While killing a dog isn't the same as if it were a person, the people responsible need to spend a few years in jail minimum.

If they are messed up enough to random and kill a dog, they are messed up enough to do worse.

This is sick and wrong, and very unfortunate. I hope the judge throws the book at whoever was responsible. :rant2:


Problematic Shitlord
20 years in prison and rehabilitation. Minimal.

A lot of killers tend to have histories of torturing and killing small animals or so I've heard. This sort of thing is sick and just proves that this kid has some serious problems that need to be worked out.


Registered Member
Torturing and killing animals is one of the major signs of a serial killer. Which is another reason I wouldn't allow the kid back in my house. He would be disowned as soon as the cops called to tell me.

Killing an animal that someone has owned and loved is up there with killing a human in my book. (I don't mind killing deer and whatnot for food, but i think that's another debate.) Hell, when my cat came home with a knife wound to his neck that was so deep you could see his jaw muscles, I nearly went on a manhunt to find the guy that did it.

What I don't get is, how did this kid's parents not notice that he killed a dog? Maybe I'm just assuming how he killed it, but I think when your kid comes home with blood on him, that might be a time to start asking questions.


rainbow 11!
I'm wondering that as well.

Also, what the hell did they do with the body?

That's fucked up though. :/ Poor dog... I hate it when people abuse animals.


Registered Member
Rob Zombie's take on Halloween had little Michael Myers killing his pet rats and a cat and then photographic it.

This child needs to be treated psychologically before he becomes a member of the crime community going in and out of jail for minor offenses before snapping and taking a human life.


4 legs good 2 legs bad
That's really fucked up. Definitely deserves a harsh penalty, at least several years in prison.