Movies Reynolds vs. Selleck

Who is the Manliest?

  • Total voters


Son of Liberty
Much like the battle between Chuck Norris and Seagal......Its Magnum PI vs. The Bandit.... who's more manly? I have such a hard time remembering who's who.

(please note you do not have to judge off these two pictures.... I posted them only for cosmetic purposes)
Last edited:


Registered Member
Well if you're going just off manly verses Magnum PI and the Bandit then I'd say the Bandit, however, I reserve the right in saying that I don't particularly care for Burt Reynolds and would pick Selleck of him anyday.


Sultan of Swat
Staff member
I've never been a fan of Burt Reynolds, the only think that I've liked from him was his appearance in The Longest Yard, other then that he bores me. But on the other hand I've always been a fan of Tom Selleck, I remember watching Magnum P.I when I was younger, I might of seen every episodes. I also liked him in MR Baseball, what a great movie. So hands down Selleck is better in my opinion.