Renteria to SF, Khalil Greene to STL


Staff member
Figured I'd combine these two...

Giants signed shortstop Edgar Renteria, who had been with the Tigers, to a two-year, $18.5 million contract.

Renteria will probably resume hitting back in the National League -- he finished at .332/.390/.470 for the Braves in 2007 -- but whether he'll be an adequate shortstop remains to be seen. He's clearly lost some range the last couple of years, and he absolutely has to get into better shape if he hopes to stick around long enough to reach 3,000 hits (he's at 2,070 through his age-32 season). Frankly, we'd like him better at third base at this point of his career. The Giants, though, figure to drop out of the Rafael Furcal chase and keep Renteria at short. That makes Emmanuel Burriss part of the competition at second base with Kevin Frandsen and Eugenio Velez.
Cardinals acquired shortstop Khalil Greene from the Padres for RHP Mark Worrell and a player to be named.

The Padres were pretty much backed into a corner, as most of the teams smart enough to realize that Greene still had considerable value were already set at shortstop. The 29-year-old Greene is an above average defender and a career .270/.318/.484 hitter outside of Petco Park. He should be a nice upgrade for the Cardinals, though he may not stick around for more than a year
Seems to me like San Fran paid waaaay too much for an older Renteria. But they are used to given out stupid contracts. See: Zito, Barry.

I like the Greene trade for St Louis. They fill a need and dont give up much at all.


Sultan of Swat
Staff member
Greene is a great player he's tremoundous with the glove, so he's defenitely going to help the Cardinals in more ways then one.

I agree that the Giants paid way to much for Renteria, but he brings tons of stuff to the table, he has a good bat, great glove and he's been in many situations which can help a lot of players on that team.

Good pick up by both teams.


Registered Member
San Fran did give too much for Renteria. But. Being back in the NL should help him because he wasn't fairing very well in the AL for whatever reason. *coughshouldhaveneverleftstlcough*

I also like the addition of Greene. He's a very talented player. He doesn't hit for average but he's got some pop and is a very good defender.

An upgrade over Cesar Izturis imo.


Registered Member
As a Dodger fan, I couldn't be happier that Brian Sabean signed Renteria. I hope they have fun struggling next year (As you can tell, Dodgers fans hate the Giants and vice versa, and while we didn't win it all, seeing San Francisco sign Barry Zito, Aaron Rowand and Renteria to these hilarious contracts make me giggle). I'm glad they overpaid for a .270 batting average and a .317 on-base percentage.

On the other hand, Khalil Greene is a FINE shortstop, a gritty, hard-nosed hustler who's power is underrated. And while he hit just .213, he was battlinmg injuries. He's an addition to SS over David Exckstein (at least defensively). Good pickup for St. Louis, bad pick up for San Fran.