2007 Brady vs. 2011 Rodgers: Who's better?

[Babe_Ruth]

I know the season isn't over yet, but dating to last year, the Packers have won 17 straight and many people in that timeframe have said Rodgers is having the best stretch of QB play ever. So, just curious, who would you take?

I know you can't go wrong with either of them. But please choose one of them and tell me why you'd take that quarterback over the other.

 

[2010Dolby]

I dont like either quarterbacks. Iv always disliked the Patriots and the Packers. Not sure why but its just kinda the general feel of thsoe two teams in my area of Nebraska and it's rubbed off on me.

That being said, Im a reasonable person who can harshly dislike a football player but still respect what they do. Im going to pick Rodgers. He seems less selfish and like he puts the good of the team above personal progress. I can respect that.

 

[Konshentz]

Whether or not you like or respect them has nothing to to do with which one of them is the better player.

My answer? I'll wait until Rodgers has played all 16 games.

 

[2010Dolby]

Whether or not you like or respect them has nothing to to do with which one of them is the better player.

My answer? I'll wait until Rodgers has played all 16 games.

I said I dont like either of them but I respect Aaron Rodgers. And the reason I respect him is the same reason for why I think hes a better QB. He wants to get a W for his team, not for his stat book. So yes, I think he's an all around better player.

 

[Konshentz]

You don't think Rodgers would try to break Brady's record if he had the chance?

 

[2010Dolby]

To be completely honest, yes he would. But thats the greed part of a person. Every human has a point where theyll crave their own benefit over anothers. In general hes a good and self-less guy. Although, I would never root for him.